The wellfounded fear of persecution standard in asylum. The refugee act of 19802 was enacted to provide a discre. Buttenwieser fund of the tides foundation, and the eastman kodak in the works. Originally shown as part of the pov series on pbs, wellfounded fear examines the united states system for granting political asylum and the refugees caught within it. Uscis provided part two of its asylum officer basic training lesson plan on asylum eligibility. Onge, director, graduate theological union cooperative summer session. What are the key elements of proving a wellfounded fear of. Aila uscis provides raio combined training course on. Aila uscis provides raio combined training course on well. I got the idea to put this mixtape together in the spring of 2011.
Wellfounded fear is a feature documentary film that examines what goes on behind the electronic doors of the asylum office, the dramatic reallife stage where american ideals about human rights collide with the nearly impossible. Wellfounded fear by tom leclair olin frederick, inc. The subjective fear is established when an applicant is found to have testified credibly concerning their fear of return. Adjudicating the religious beliefs of an asylum seekers. Discussion of how to present key elements of your claim of a wellfounded fear of persecution. The key to an asylum claim is proving that you face a wellfounded fear of persecution. Imagine that your life has fallen apart maybe youve been tortured or raped, or maybe youve gotten out just in time. Go time bonus track well founded fear is a project that has been in the works for some time now, and i am beyond excited to finally share it with the world. Behind the scenes are the applicants, attorneys and translators. June 5, 2000 wellfounded fear, a poignant, balanced report about the process of seeking political asylum in the u. Well founded fear is a 2000 documentary film from directors shari robertson and michael camerini.
The primary focus of this lesson is the determination as to whether an applicant has established a reasonable possibility of suffering future harm in the country of nationality. Wellfounded fear is a 2000 documentary film from directors shari robertson and michael camerini. To be granted asylum, applicants must demonstrate a wellfounded fear that their lives would be endangered were they to be deported. The congressional battle to save political asylum in america pdf full. It comes with some aspects which people will like including the multiplayer suite which is very good.
Aug 12, 2014 well founded fear a feature documentary by shari robertson and michael camerini distributed by roco films international well founded fear is a stirring, evocative, and utterly. Wellfounded fear is made possible by grants from the ford foundation, the spunk fund inc. This module provides guidance on how to determine whether an applicant has established a reasonable possibility of suffering future harm in the country of nationality or last habitual residence. See asylum adjudications supplement presumption raised by past persecution. To establish a well founded fear of persecution within the meaning of the refugee definition, an applicant must show that he or she has. Uscis provided the raio combined training course on well founded fear. While it is generally agreed that the wellfounded fear requirement limits refugee status to persons who face an actual, forwardlooking risk of being persecuted the objective element, linguistic ambiguity has resulted in a divergence of views regarding whether the test. Migration act 1958 sect 5j meaning of wellfounded fear. Claiming asylum if you fear, but havent experienced. To be granted asylum, applicants must demonstrate a wellfounded fear that best dvd prices. Aila uscis provides lesson plan on wellfounded fear. Wellfounded fear challenges us as viewers to think about whether government institutions reflect our political beliefs, including our level of commitment to protecting individuals from persecution.
Well founded fear focuses on both the pleas of immigrants to stay in the united states, and the consideration of their cases by ins officers. In a claim for refugee status, the issue is not whether the claimant had good reason to fear persecution in the past, but whether, at the time the claim is being assessed, the claimant has good grounds for fearing persecution in the future. On this dramatic, reallife stage, american ideals about human rights collide with the nearly impossible task of trying to learn the truth from asylumseekers. Migration act 1958 sect 5j meaning of wellfounded fear of. Chapter 5 wellfounded fear immigration and refugee. The primary focus of this lesson is the determination as to whether an applicant has established a reasonable. Uscis provided the raio combined training course on wellfounded fear.
Wellfounded fear 2000 directed by shari robertson and michael camerini the epidavros project epidoko pictures new york, ny. The asylumseekers are at once hopeful and heartbreaking, at times too slick and polished, and in other cases painfully timid. The michigan guidelines on wellfounded fear by colloquium. Wellfounded fear wellfounded fear and practicing asylum law provide excellent training and we strongly recommend that they be used to train legal aid providers, interpreters, and judges as well as for raising awareness of the plight of asylum seekers. Elements of well founded fear to establish a well founded fear of persecution within the meaning of the refugee definition, an applicant must show that he or she has. Macarthur foundation, the emma lazarus fund, and the soros documentary fund of the open society institute, the overbrook foundation, the peter l. If people are looking for the first person shooter game which only offers them with the challenge but fear at the same time, f. In other words, the applicant should truly be afraid of returning, but that fear shouldnt be out of proportion to reality. Under the stipulation that an asylum seeker must have wellfounded fear to be granted refugee status, room exists for climate refugees to be included within the legalistic language. Since then, i have been working nonstop to make it everything that it turned out to be. The reasoning is that if an applicant establishes past persecution, a rebuttable presumption of a wellfounded fear of future persecution is created unless the officer establishes that there has been a fundamental change in circumstances, like no more. Well founded fear is made possible by grants from the ford foundation, the spunk fund inc. This well founded fear standard does not necessarily mean torture, killing, imprisonment, or harassment or that you are specifically targeted for persecution or that you have an economic hardship or a repressive. The definition of convention refugee is forwardlooking.
Go time bonus track wellfounded fear is a project that has been in the works for some time now, and i am beyond excited to finally share it with the world. Well founded fear is a feature documentary film that examines what goes on behind the electronic doors of the asylum office, the dramatic reallife stage where american ideals about human rights collide with the nearly impossible task of trying to know the truth. Well founded fear, a documentary showing a a revealing look inside the inss political asylum process. This wellfounded fear standard does not necessarily mean torture, killing, imprisonment, or harassment or that you are specifically targeted for persecution or that you have an economic hardship or a. Debates surrounding the interpretation of the wellfounded fear requirement centre upon whether there is a need to demonstrate two elements. Well founded fear 2000 directed by shari robertson and michael camerini the epidavros project epidoko pictures new york, ny. As a key factor for determining the refugee status according to the article ia2 of the 1951 convention relating to the status of refugees the term wellfounded fear contains a. Tom leclair, well founded fear olin frederick, 2000 we are three days into 2010 as i write this, and i have already sent my first book flying out the window, tom leclairs well founded fear. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. While it is generally agreed that the well founded fear requirement limits refugee status to persons who face an actual, forwardlooking risk of being persecuted the objective element, linguistic ambiguity has resulted in a divergence of views regarding whether the test also. To print the pdf on this page please use the print. Groundbreaking, as well as devastating if its lifeanddeath drama youre looking for, with entire futures hinging on a few words, this is watch wellfounded fear online vimeo on demand on vimeo.
Is there a subjective element in the refugee conventions. Wellfounded fear is an evocative documentary about what goes on behind the electronic doors of the asylum office at the u. At issue in every case are the requirements of asylum. The key to an asylum claim is proving that you face a well founded fear of persecution. Wellfounded fear the michigan journal of international law. Only one in two hundred refugees is granted asylum in the u. How democracy works now, wellfounded fear, these girls are missing, becoming the buddha in l. The applicant must have a wellfounded fear of persecution in his or her home country. This wellfounded fear of persecution factor may arise before heshe leaves the country andor after heshe leaves the country, persons in the latter category being known as refugees sur place. Rent wellfounded fear 2000 on dvd and bluray netflix. An unprecedented inside look at the immigration and naturalization service ins, awardwinning filmmakers shari robertson and michael camerini take their cameras behind locked doors, where bureaucrats decide the fates of thousands of asylumseekers each year. How democracy works now, well founded fear, these girls are missing, becoming the buddha in l. Well founded fear bill hing, professor of law, university of california at davis david martin, professor of law, university of virginia cara mertes, executive producer, p. Wellfounded fear, a documentary showing a a revealing look inside the inss political asylum process.
Part iii examines the international law bases of the relevant statutory language. In contrast to the question of whether an applicant is unable or unwilling to avail himself or herself of the country of origins protection, the assessment of wellfounded fear does not comprise any evaluation of an applicants state of mind. Migration act 1958 sect 5j meaning of wellfounded fear of persecution 1 for the purposes of the application of this act and the regulations to a particular person, the person has a wellfounded fear of persecution if. Despite true and terrifying stories of torture and mistreatment, its often up to how well the translator presents the case and how sensitive are the ears of the asylum officer to decide a persons fate.
Wellfounded fear wellfounded fear shari robertson and michael camerini behind the lens. An individual qualifies as a convention refugee only if he or she has a well founded fear of being persecuted. The applicant must have a well founded fear of persecution in his or her home country. Accordingly, the bia did not address whether the government had met its burden under 8 c. Elements of wellfounded fear to establish a wellfounded fear of persecution within the meaning of the refugee definition, an applicant must show that he or she has. What are the key elements of proving a wellfounded fear. She legally entered greece on august 23, 1998, and shortly thereafter was granted a residence permit and work permit. The wellfounded fear of persecution standard in asylum proceedings. Wellfounded fear a feature documentary by shari robertson and michael camerini distributed by roco films international wellfounded fear is a stirring, evocative, and utterly. The well founded fear of persecution standard in asylum proceedings.
Introduction the history of laws providing asylum to aliens in this country is marked by varying and confusing standards for the granting of asylum. Wellfounded fear full frame documentary film festival. Foreigners that are already in the united states, having fled their home countries, have the opportunity to apply for asylum through the ins. To be granted asylum, applicants must demonstrate a wellfounded fear. Wellfounded fear documentary film macarthur foundation. Wellfounded fear documentary, throws light on the tortuous experiences of the asylum seekers. The wellfounded fear of persecution element of the refugee definition is assessed both objectively is the fear well founded. Reaction of the video wellfounded fear documentary essay. To meet the criteria for well founded fear, the fear must be subjectively genuine and objectively reasonable.
For the asylum seeker, it is the situation of life or death and heshe is at the mercy of the decision makers, who have to weigh the pros and cons of a variety of crossinterests. According to the united nations handbook on procedures and criteria for determining refugee status, a person in flight must demonstrate he or she has a well founded fear of persecution for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group, or political opinion. Wellfounded fear has been defined as when the applicant has a subjectively genuine and an objectively reasonable fear. This documentary film takes us to an indepth look at the asylum process of the federal u. Wellfounded fear postponed till further notice presented. Wellfounded fear focuses on both the pleas of immigrants to stay in the united states, and the consideration of their cases by ins officers. The filmmakers were given unprecedented access to the process, including cameras in normally closed asylum interviews, along with interviews of the people seeking asylum, the asylum officers who hear the cases and make the decisions, and their supervisors. Meaning of well founded fear of persecution 1 for the purposes of the application of this act and the regulations to a particular person, the person has a well founded fear of persecution if. As such, the requirement of wellfounded fear is comprised of both subjective and objective clauses. Originally shown as part of the pov series on pbs, well founded fear examines the united states system for granting political asylum and the refugees caught within it.
Suvasini patel, director, high impact television, p. Discussion of how to present key elements of your claim of a well founded fear of persecution. Filmed in ins offices in new york and new jersey, the. All have the same desire freedom to stay in america. Tom leclair, wellfounded fear olin frederick, 2000 we are three days into 2010 as i write this, and i have already sent my first book flying out the window, tom leclairs wellfounded fear. If a persons case establishes a wellfounded fear of hisher home. As a result of events occurring before 1 january 1951 and owing to a well founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion, is outside the country of his nationality and is unable, or owing to such fear, is unwilling to avail himself of the protection of. Since the term wellfounded fear 3s used in section 208 as well as in section 207, the court further noted, the same lower standard of proof. It will be demonstrated that legislative history, united states case law, and international policy and practice, indicate that the united states governments stringent administrative interpretation of the phrase wellfounded fear of persecution is erroneous. Well founded fear new docs only one in two hundred refugees is granted asylum in the u. Please login or register to purchase or borrow resources. An individual qualifies as a convention refugee only if he or she has a wellfounded fear of being persecuted.
566 454 1063 928 494 239 188 360 1161 1259 1565 1306 613 1578 948 172 71 71 745 800 1180 272 623 1236 451 149 678 1395 365 1044 1429